Head Gasket? Signs not adding up?

McLaggin411

New member
Joined
Mar 31, 2011
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Sierra 1500 SLE 5.3L 4x4

Check engine light came on and decided to first give it a check to see if anything obvious stood out. There was some white foam on the oil cap, but it did that last year when the weather turned suddenly warm, and I drive a short distance every day.

Unfortunately everything seems to point to the head gasket, but it does not seem to add up.

1.) Oil looks fine (although a bit of sludge seemed apparent)
2.) No white smoke, or coolant smell in exhaust.
3.) No noticeable loss of HP
4.) Coolant runs low, but never runs out. No matter what, a short time after I add some in, it goes to a point below the indicated line and then just stays there. Never runs dry, engine never runs hot.
5.) There was some white foam on the oil cap.
6.) No water/coolant drops on the dipstick.
7.) For the first time ever, it looked like the coolant may be dirty. Maybe its because I was looking for it, but should the coolant look as clear as when it was added?

Sounds like the HG right? What I want to know is if this is an issue that can slowly grow progressively worse over time until it causes a check engine light? I figured that once its blown...its blown, and the issues would appear and grow worse quickly.

I have twice taken this truck into the shop over the past 2 years because of a check engine light that stayed on, and spent more then was necessary to be told I need a new gas cap. Is my truck crying wolf again...or is it for real this time.

If it is the HG, does the price vary, or is it a pretty standard fix? Any hint as to the general cost would be great. Thanks in advance for any advice, I have already learned a lot just reading through the forums!
 
Last edited:
I think your head gasket is fine, condensation in or around the cap is normal for short trips. If you had oil in the rad you would know it, it looks worse then dirty.
 
Sierra 1500 SLE 5.3L 4x4

Check engine light came on and decided to first give it a check to see if anything obvious stood out. There was some white foam on the oil cap, but it did that last year when the weather turned suddenly warm, and I drive a short distance every day.

Unfortunately everything seems to point to the head gasket, but it does not seem to add up.

1.) Oil looks fine (although a bit of sludge seemed apparent)
2.) No white smoke, or coolant smell in exhaust.
3.) No noticeable loss of HP
4.) Coolant runs low, but never runs out. No matter what, a short time after I add some in, it goes to a point below the indicated line and then just stays there. Never runs dry, engine never runs hot.
5.) There was some white foam on the oil cap.
6.) No water/coolant drops on the dipstick.
7.) For the first time ever, it looked like the coolant may be dirty. Maybe its because I was looking for it, but should the coolant look as clear as when it was added?

Sounds like the HG right? What I want to know is if this is an issue that can slowly grow progressively worse over time until it causes a check engine light? I figured that once its blown...its blown, and the issues would appear and grow worse quickly.

I have twice taken this truck into the shop over the past 2 years because of a check engine light that stayed on, and spent more then was necessary to be told I need a new gas cap. Is my truck crying wolf again...or is it for real this time.

If it is the HG, does the price vary, or is it a pretty standard fix? Any hint as to the general cost would be great. Thanks in advance for any advice, I have already learned a lot just reading through the forums!

Next oil service, have your engine oil analyzed for cross contamination. Common area of coolant seep is from your water pump gasket on the 5.3 vortec.

As for your check engine light, what was the DTC code. The other thing you may want to do is add a bottle of http://www.marvelmysteryoil.com/ in to your engine oil about 500 miles before you service your engine oil or add a bottle of http://www.seafoamsales.com/ about 50 miles before you service the engine oil.

This will clean out the internal oil passageways and get you engine running 100% again like the day it was started.

Good luck and keep us posted. ;)
 
Don't over react until you pull the OBDII code and see what it is. Stop buy an autozone type place and have them check the code. Go from there. I also would suggest that anyone who plays with their trucks or cars go out and buy a code reader. They are cheap enough and at least you can see what the problem is. Oh and if you do make sure it has the erase capability.
 


Back
Top